The Shorn Tech Tree (Public Draft)
A catalogue of technologies that did not find a way
An in-progress catalogue of technologies that were abandoned, foreclosed or left unbuilt. It focuses especially on still-unconquered frontiers and high-watermarks of the global technology wavefront: technologies that were not just superseded by a ‘replacement technology’, but which had something distinct that (to date) no one went on to achieve. This open public draft holds my own entries and those reviewed so far: it contains 495 cases, out of 1,200 cases collected in total. This list likely still contains errors.
Where the branches were cut
Key: decision to pursue working prototype widespread deployment significant impact terminated hard limit
| Military and security | Civil transport and space | Other civil domains | |||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| How far it got | Cases | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| Summit | 19 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| High branches | Procurement and deployment bungles | 0 | |||||||||||||||||||||
| 7 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| Branches | 84 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| 43 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| 2 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| 28 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| Trunk | 98 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| 50 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| 73 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| 18 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| Roots | 50 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| 20 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| Soil | 2 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
How to read this figure
Rows are types of abandonment, arranged as a tree: the higher the row, the further a technology got before it was cut. The roots hold ideas that never left paper; the trunk, research and prototypes; the branches, technologies that were deployed and then lost or stunted; the summit, the few that only one or two parties ever achieved. The soil holds losses that cannot be pinned to single projects. The line beside each row sketches the typical path, with ticks for the checkpoints it passed (key above). Columns are domains; dot area shows the number of cases. Click a row, a column or a dot to filter the list below.
A note on case selection
298 of the 495 cases are military, nuclear or aerospace projects. That reflects the sources used so far (cancelled defence and space projects are unusually well documented) and should not be read as a finding. For the same reason, an empty or thin cell says little about whether such cases exist; biotechnology in particular is probably under-represented.
495 cases
Steep plateaus 19
Technologies that were eventually achieved by one or a few parties, but which frustrated most parties that tried their hand at them.
Transport & land vehicles
US high-speed rail
''In The Second Age of Rail, author Murray Hughes notes that “so many proposals for high-speed railways in the USA have been dreamt up and shot down that it is almost unsporting to list them.”
Civil aircraft
Jet engines
High-altitude platform stations
e.g. long-endurance 'pseudo-satellites / atmospheric satellites
US supersonic airliners
Military aircraft
Various giant military ground effect vehicles US failure
German and Soviet stealth aircraft
Airborne early warning system UK failure
Civil space systems & space exploration
US repeated attempts to develop nuclear-powered spacecraft propulsion
Independent national orbital launch capacity 'UK Black Arrow / Brazilian VLS
National space-launcher programs that failed via voluntary cancellation vs. fatal launchpad explosion
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Road-mobile ballistic missiles
US: abandoned the 'Small ICBM' and Hard Mobile Launcher in 1992
British failures to indigenously develop a ballistic missile
Biological & chemical weapons
Bioweapons Iraq, South Africa, Aum Shinrikyo
Naval (military)
Aircraft super-carriers
Soviet Union / Russia failure; several attempted, only Admiral Kuznetsov deployed
Supercavitating torpedoes
USSR/Russia success; US abandoned in the 1950s for underwater stealth instead
Other weapons & military systems
Iraqi pre-2003 attempts to indigenously develop extremely powerful self-propelled artillery
Offensive cyberwar programs
Numerous other military programs less stringently
Energy
Geothermal electricity in China
Despite vast hydrothermal resources, installed capacity stuck at ~28 MW because solar/wind supply chains and incumbents have crowded geothermal out at every level.
Health & medicine
Public biotech startups as an asset class Biotech startup attrition
Analysis of 803 post-2000 US biotech startups showing ~31% outright failure, only ~7% gaining value since IPO
Locally atrophied branches 7
Situations where a country used to be able to build something, but no longer can (while other actors still can and do).
Other weapons & military systems
Artillery shell production
Next-generation armored vehicles arguably
The U.S. Army has tried and failed for twenty years to procure a new tank; nearly all programs to develop next-generation armored vehicles (Future Combat Systems' Manned Ground Vehicles; Ground Combat Vehicle) have been repeatedly cancelled. Currently aiming to develop the Optionally Manned Fighting Vehicle as replacement for the M-2 Bradley IFV
Energy
Nuclear power
Computing, digital & communications
USSR / Russian indigenous computing architectures
Developed the MESM four years after US computers; the BESM-6 (1958) was competitive; but was cut short when the Soviet military pressured the government to adopt the IBM model 360 as the core of their Unified Computer System.
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
US shipbuilding capacity
'Commercial shipbuilding in the U.S. is virtually nonexistent: in 2022, the U.S. had just five large oceangoing commercial ships on order, compared to China’s 1,794 and South Korea’s 734. The U.S. Navy estimates that China’s shipbuilding capacity is 232 times our own.'
Shipbuilding industry
Interchangeable-parts manufacture of musket locks in France (Blanc system) Honoré Blanc's interchangeable musket locks, France, 1790-1806
Honoré Blanc assembled muskets from randomly drawn parts in Paris in 1790; interchangeability of flintlock parts was later achieved on a large scale at Roanne. In 1806 the French government scrapped the method (open.edu).
Withered branches 84
Technologies that saw only (very) limited societal adoption or deployment before being (almost or entirely) phased out, without being replaced by a successor technology that obviously outperforms them.
Transport & land vehicles
Wind wagons and 'sailing carriages'
(wind-driven carriages fitted out with sails); saw limited use in China, during the 6th century and during the Ming Dynasty, as well as in the 1800s on the American great plains)
Lightweight copper-cooled automotive engines
'Movable pier' seashore electric railways e.g. 'Seashore Electric Railway'
High-performance 1930s steam cars
e.g. the Dobble Model E; virtually silent compared to gasoline engines, faster, easier to maintain and operate (lacking transmission), although it needed around 90 seconds to heat up from a cold start. Downsides included the price, and the perfectionism of Abner Doble
Wood gas vehicles
Gyrobus
Electric bus using flywheel energy storage --storing energy in a rotor as rotational energy--rather than overhead wires
Wankel rotary engine in mass-market cars GM Rotary Combustion Engine
GM's Wankel-based rotary engine program, begun with a $50 million licence in 1970 and aimed at the Chevrolet Vega; postponed in 1974 over emissions and sub-standard fuel economy, with the ill-timed oil embargo crisis a contributing factor.
Civil aircraft
Passenger airships
Flying boats
Dominated interwar air travel, becoming the first aircraft to ferry a sitting US president; however, during WWII, the government built many concrete runways for heavy bombers, to the advantage of competing land-based airliners
Soviet and Anglo-French supersonic airliners
Circular-wing aircraft
Davis wing
High-aspect-ratio low-drag airfoil designed in 1937 using an unconventional reverse-engineered teardrop method, used most famously on the B-24 Liberator and B-32 Dominator.
'Airmail pickup'
Nonstop plane package pickup and delivery without landing, using airplane-mounted collection hooks and drop-off canisters
Aircraft car ferries
Blimps
(there is a claim that there are only 25 blimps left in the world, but it is hard to trace back)
Mobile aviation lounge system
Washington Dulles Eames-designed airport driver-operated lounges to deliver passengers directly to parked aircraft; did not scale with passenger growth
Solar-powered aircraft arguably
Military aircraft
(USSR) giant military ekranoplan
Ground effect planes combining the payload of a ship with the speed of an aircraft
Counter-illumination based active camouflage
('Yehudi lights') for aircraft
Aircraft 'plasma stealth'
e.g. Cesium-laced fuel to create radar-absorbing exhaust plumes
Civil space systems & space exploration
Human spaceflight
Numerous US space programs; in fact, Artemis is the first new human NASA initiative to survive a presidential transition since the 1980s (Joseph Levine); though even that has been significantly critiqued –
Sea launch
Launch of orbital rockets from ships or from mobile / floating maritime launch platforms, to enable rocket launch from the equator, increasing payload capacity. / briefly achieved between 1999 and 2014 by Sea Launch, a multinational company, which put its operations in hiatus after the Russian invasion of Ukraine
Nuclear-powered satellites or spaceships
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Fractional orbital bombardment warhead delivery systems
Anti-satellite (ASAT) weapons based on co-orbital 'kamikaze satellite' weapons with fragmentation warheads e.g. 'Istrebitel Sputnikov'
Brief deployment in 1970s and 1980s, placed under moratorium in 1983 because it produced dangerous debris.
ASAT weapons based on nuclear warheads detonated in space
No country today is known to deploy offensive neutron bombs debatable
But Russia apparently deploys some on ballistic missile defense; moreover, in practice all dial-a-yield warheads that have 10 kiloton or lower as an option, can functionally serve as neutron bombs
Biological & chemical weapons
Psychochemical drug cluster bombs
Biological anti-crop bombs
Mycotoxin-based (fungal) biological weapons
Many forms of 'super tear gas' arguably Riot Control Agents
Renounced by the US in 1975
Battlefield chemical weapons in major-power militaries Chlorine, mustard gas and nerve agents (sarin), WWI to Cold War; US no-first-use 1969
Battlefield chemical agents (chlorine, mustard gas, sarin), used massively in WWI and stockpiled through the Cold War, abandoned by major militaries: US no-first-use 1969; US and Russian stockpiles largely destroyed. Reasons: cheap masks and suits, persistence hindering manoeuvre, short nerve-agent shelf-life, inferiority to high explosives.
Naval (military)
Steam-powered submarines
(notorious death traps)
Coal-powered
Paddle steamer freshwater aircraft carriers (USS Wolverine and USS Sable)
Military hydrofoils
Including (1) the USS Plainview, a two hundred foot long fast submarine hunting ship.
- Decommissioned after only 268 hours foilborne
Counter-illumination based active camouflage
Such as diffused lighting camouflage for ships
Nuclear-powered surface combatant vessels beyond submarines and aircraft carriers
(e.g. 'The Nuclear Fleet'); very limited deployment of 9 US nuclear-powered cruisers in the Cold War; Russia currently operates one nuclear battlecruiser, back at sea since nearly 3 decades of refits
Civil maritime
Extremely large steam ships
e.g. *SS Great Eastern*; a 4,000 passenger paddle steamer, capable of around-the-world trips; would be the largest ship for 40 years, but bankrupted its company and investors
Trolley canal boats
In the early 20th century, several European countries electrified canal barge haulage by running trolley wires along towpaths, replacing horse teams with electric motors on the boats. The system was efficient and eliminated animal cruelty, but was killed by road trucking and the general decline of inland waterway freight after WWII
Nuclear-powered cruise ships
Chain-hauled steam river tugs Chain boats / Kettenschleppschiffe / toueurs; La Ville de Sens (M. Dietz, c.1850); Elbe, Neckar, Main, Seine, Danube, c.1850–1950
Steam river tugs hauling themselves and barge strings along a steel chain laid on the riverbed, suited to shallow, fast-flowing rivers. Prototyped in M. Dietz's La Ville de Sens (c.1850), they spread across Europe until more powerful paddle steamers and canalization displaced them.
Other weapons & military systems
Flame tanks Churchill Crocodile / M67 Zippo
Flame tanks: tanks fitted with flamethrowers (e.g. Churchill Crocodile, M67 Zippo), used widely in WWII against fortifications; range under 150 m, and late-war infantry anti-tank weapons outranged them. Out of the US arsenal since 1978, replaced by thermobaric and other incendiary weapons.
Missile tank Soviet IT-1 Object 150
Armoured vehicles filling the tank role but armed only with guided missiles. Several nations built prototypes, notably the Soviet Union under Khrushchev; the Soviet IT-1 missile-armed tank destroyer saw limited service: ~220 built 1968–70, withdrawn by 1972.
Steam-powered tanks
Sawback bayonets
Multi-turreted tanks e.g. T-35
Bat bombs
Timed incendiary bombs strapped to bats dropped in bomb canisters
Infantry-portable tactical nuclear weapon launchers
Super-lightweight but powerful assault rifles firing caseless ammunition or flechettes
(fin-stabilized projectiles) or gyroscopically stabilized rockets ('microjets')
Land mines debatable
Even though many great powers did not sign the Ottawa mine ban treaty in 1997, its entry still had a marked effect. In the '90s, 25,000 people were killed or injured by land mines each year; by 2013, that number had fallen to 3,300., and tens of millions of mines have been destroyed. (more recently, this has slightly reversed, with annual landmine deaths and injuries rising to 5,700 in 2023)
Surveillance, intelligence & espionage
Automated electronic-sensor battlefield Operation Igloo White, 1968–73
Attempted battlefield awareness through >20,000 air-dropped sensors scattered across the Ho Chi Minh Trail, to direct strike aircraft. The North Vietnamese fooled with animals, urine buckets, and recordings; (source). As Kevin Baker notes: ''The system could be fooled because nobody in the process could look at what it was sensing. The Air Force claimed forty-six thousand trucks destroyed or damaged over the course of the campaign. The CIA reported that the claims for a single year exceeded the total number of trucks believed to exist in all of North Vietnam.22 The system’s own output was the only measure of its performance, and nobody outside the system had standing to challenge it. Air Force historian Bernard Nalty later called the service’s casualty computations “an exercise in metaphysics rather than mathematics” and his colleague Earl Tilford concluded that ’the Air Force succeeded only in fooling itself” the program was working.""
Energy
Atomic pacemakers
Polar autonomous nuclear lighthouses
Nuclear desalination
Receded after early Soviet projects; Israel has conducted a decades-long failed effort to develop it, after US policymakers concluded in 1968 that offering it a reactor for that purpose would not sway it from its military nuclear program
(US) breeder reactors
Nuclear batteries
Leaded gasoline contestable
Computing, digital & communications
Infrastructure for real-time cybernetic control of the economy Cybersin
Carphones and in-flight telephone services
Aerial wireless internet network using stratospheric balloons
Ternary (trinary) computers using ternary base 3 logic
Which would have shown promise for implementing fast (1.58-bit) ternary LLMs and other AI applications, in lieu of floating point arithmetic
- Ternary computer abandoned after ministry's forced standardization.
Meteor burst radio communications for long-haul data links JANET (Canada, 1952–c.1960); COMET (NATO SHAPE, 1965); Alaska Air Command MBC and DARPA/SAIC AMBCS (1970s)
Radio data links bouncing VHF bursts off meteor ionisation trails over up to 2,250 km. Ran during the 1950s and 1960s, when interest faded with satellite communications.
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Urban fish ponds low-tech sewage treatment
For centuries and up to the mid 20th century, cities in Asia and parts of Europe treated sewage by channelling it through fish ponds — the fish consumed organic waste, produced edible protein, and the effluent emerged cleaner. The practice was eliminated by modern centralized sewage treatment, though it was often more resource-efficient. (source)
Underground pneumatic tube postal/freight networks
Used in various cities (London Post Office Railway; Chicago tunnel system) for transportation without surface congestion (source)
Linear cities
Cities designed around functionally specialized parallel sectors (e.g. transport / production / residential / parks)
Moonlight towers
1880s-1890s 100-300ft towers topped with ar lights, aimed to illuminate entire neighbourhoods
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
Hoffman kilns highly energy efficient circular brick ovens
'Group Technology' industrial improvement system
Focused on high-mix, low-volume operations of a wide variety of different parts
Agriculture
Garum Roman fermented fish sauce
An industrial-scale condiment of the Roman world, produced in factories across the Mediterranean, that vanished with the collapse of Roman trade networks. Analogous to modern fish sauce (and arguably its ancestor), it illustrates how a food technology can disappear when the logistics infrastructure supporting it collapses. (source)
DDT insecticide for agriculture and vector control
Synthetic insecticide discovered in 1939 by Paul Müller's team at Geigy; it underpinned national malaria-spraying campaigns. Insect resistance emerged from 1947, and documented harms to birds, fish and wildlife, publicised by Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (1962), led to agricultural phase-outs and bans in many countries.
Health & medicine
Vaccine for lyme disease
Environmental
'Peaceful Nuclear Explosions' for civil engineering applications
Between 1965-1988, the USSR conducted 122 nuclear explosions (yields from 0.01 to 140kt, vast majority 2-20kt) to study 13 applications; over half used for the creation of underground cavities in salt for the storage of gas condensate and deep seismic sounding. Also included limited but failed attempts to change the course of rivers. Chernobyl killed the project politically, and the tests were ended as part of a unilateral Soviet moratorium on nuclear weapons testing adopted by Gorbachev.
Intentionally rolled-back technologies (CFCs, DDT, leaded gasoline) debatable
There are also technologies that had far larger adoption, but whose adoption was intentionally rolled back (e.g. CFCs, DDTs, Leaded Gasoline); but in many such cases, as with DDT, the roll-back took quite long
Organizational & social technologies
'Internal markets' inside firms
e.g. organizations that make their different departments--appliances, human resources, IT, branding--contract with each other and compete against outside contractors, as autonomous businesses
Consumer products & novelties
Insulated retained-heat ('fireless') cookers
Late-19th-to-mid-20th-century kitchen tech offering 70–80% energy savings on long-cooked dishes, displaced by cheap fuel and electric stoves
Vin Mariani
Late 19th-century Bordeaux wine laced with cocaine; endorsed by many leaders but displaced by changing public attitudes towards narcotics
Microwave-as-stovetop replacement
Tools such as pyroceram browning skillets enabled Maillard reactions in the microwave, and a complete microwave-based kitchen. However, killed by consumer distrust for 'radiation'.
Coloured, dyed toilet paper was a popular fad in 1950s America
Microsoft Kin was a 'social networking'-focused mobile phone that cost 1BN to develop
And which flopped after its introduction in 2010;...but obviously people use their mobile phones for social networking
Flushable wet wipes
Inflatable furniture IKEA 'a.i.r' attempts in 1980s-1990s
(arguably) inflatable furniture ('IKEA 'a.i.r' attempts in 1980s-1990s')). Cheap, weightless, easy-to-maintain furniture that cut raw material and transport use; but its valves leaked, so it needed constant re-inflating. IKEA withdrew it, then briefly reintroduced a children's line about ten years later.
IMAX 15/70 rolling-loop film projectors IMAX 15/70 film projector (Peter Jones rolling loop, William Shaw), 1970 to 2000s; 41 rooms in 2026
The IMAX 15/70 film projector, built on Peter Jones's late-1960s rolling-loop film transport and scaled by William Shaw, was hand-made a few units yearly for museums. IMAX ended production as institutional demand faded and it pivoted to digital from 2007; 41 rooms remained in 2026.
Long-life household incandescent lamps Pre-1925 long-life incandescent lamps, replaced by the Phoebus cartel's 1,000-hour standard, 1925-1939
Household bulbs of 1924 could burn for 2,500 hours or more. By early 1925 the Phoebus cartel had codified 1,000 hours for a pear-shaped household bulb and fined factories whose bulbs lasted longer or shorter than the regulated life (Wikipedia).
Telephone newspapers and theatre-by-telephone services 1890-1944
Telephone newspapers transmitted news and entertainment to subscribers: Paris from 1890, Budapest from 1893, London from 1895. Radio supplanted most; London closed in 1925 and Paris in 1932; Budapest's wire network, destroyed in World War II, ended in 1944 (Wikipedia).
Inferior leaps 1
Competitions where a worse technology won, temporarily or persistently.
Computing, digital & communications
OSI X.400 message handling with built-in encryption
Message Handling System of the telecom-industry OSI protocol suite (published 1984; 1988 Blue Book), using ASN.1 encoding and X.500/X.509 directory-based public keys for end-to-end encryption. More efficient than many alternatives but lost to SMTP internet email, because ASN.1 messaging failed and no global directory materialized; survives in military, ICAO aviation, EDI.
Underpowered dreams 43
Technologies that were pioneered many decades ago, to anticipated significant impacts; and which have indeed arrived and stuck around, but which remain far more marginal in their usage than expected.
Transport & land vehicles
Pneumatic 'atmospheric railway'
Gas bag vehicles
Giant civilian hovercraft
Segway two-wheeled
Self-balancing personal transporter (Steve Jobs apparently claimed that it would be 'as big a deal as the PC')
Self-driving trains only deployment in a couple cities
Electric velomobiles
Fully faired recumbent tricycles with small electric-assist motors, with 80× energy efficiency advantages over automobiles at similar speeds
Civil aircraft
Civilian jet packs arguably
Military aircraft
Dedicated stealth helicopters
Military jet packs
Civil space systems & space exploration
Space Shuttle
After the first flight of Columbia in 1981, NASA maintained that its fleet would manage a cadence of 50 launches a year by the late 1980s, at $10 million a flight. In reality, the shuttle effort peaked at 9 flights in 1985 (subsequently falling off after a 2-year post Challenger freeze), with costs of roughly $847 million - $1.5 billion per flight. "Retirement came 135 flights and $196 billion later in 2011.", and design flaws had caused the destruction of two of the five orbiters (Deudney Dark Skies)
Reusable manned orbital and sub-orbital spaceplanes contestable
Given most programs have been retired, are unmanned, or remain in experimental stages
Orbital data centers uncertain
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Strategic ballistic missile defence arguably
(i.e. missile defense systems that can intercept intercontinental ballistic missiles, rather than intermediate-range tactical ballistic missiles (e.g. Scuds)). Although the US.'s Ground-based Midcourse Defense (GMD) system is operationally deployed in a small capacity, its test success record (in artificially simplified tests) is roughly half (source)
Civil maritime
Fletner rotor sails
Other weapons & military systems
Sonic weapons arguably
Infrasonic, sonic and ultrasonic acoustic weapons (see also source)
Surveillance, intelligence & espionage
Over-the-horizon (OTH) radar
Detecting aircraft and ICBMs at extreme distances by exploiting the ionosphere's ability to reflect HF radio waves.
Energy
Energy storage in superconducting coils Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES)
Superconducting magnetic energy storage: near-lossless, millisecond-response storage in a superconducting coil, proposed in 1969 for grid load-levelling and first run in 1980 (Bonneville Power Administration). Forces on the coil cap it near 12 kJ/kg, about a hundredth of lithium-ion, so it survives in power-quality and fusion niches.
Nuclear power given constrained uptake
Floating nuclear power stations
Stirling heat engines arguably
District heating with industrial waste heat arguably
Computing, digital & communications
Liquid computers
Numerous approaches since 1900; resulting in viable albeit slower computing systems
Stateless (thin client) computing paradigm
Optical computing paradigm arguably heralded as the successor of electronics during the 1980s
MOOCs and online education arguably
Immersive technologies and Virtual Reality
Which see some niche use cases but which have not produced the large parallel worlds seeing near-universal take-up, and which have seen many major projects cancelled or withdrawn from market, including the Apple Vision Pro and the Metaverse (shut down after $80bn spent)
Stereoscopic (3D) television
Holographic television
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Mobile homes arguably
'Phalanstère' self-contained
Integrated utopian commune buildings, designed for 500-2,000 people living together in a structure integrating urban and rural features. Dozens were attempted across Europe and the Americas; nearly all collapsed within a few years
Earthscrapers
i.e. buildings providing many stories of permanent living space below ground
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
3d printers arguably
"The next big thing for at least 20 years"
Agriculture
Fruit trenches
For cultivation of subtropical plants in freezing temperatures
Algae based biofuel
Subsea farming greenhouses
e.g. Nemo's Garden: modular underwater hydroponic greenhouses, transparent pods anchored to the seabed, with a pilot plant of nine biospheres off Noli, Italy, 80 metres from shore, aimed at regions facing water scarcity or climate stress.
Health & medicine
Viral phage therapy
Use of bacteriophages for treating bacterial infections without inducing antibiotic resistance
Therapeutic use of psychedelic substances
Biohacking
AI in radiology arguably
Organizational & social technologies
Universal language
(e.g. Esperanto); numerous attempts over centuries (e.g. at least since the 1700s); such languages have been constructed but even the most well-known never grew beyond a small base
Consumer products & novelties
Digitally Enhanced Food i.e. the use of 'sonic seasoning'
Augmented reality food overlays, and others to enhance taste experience. Extremely limited takeup
Whole-house smart homes unified app/voice-driven home control struggle with integration failure as the number of connected devices rises arguably
Running shoes using mechanical cushioning e.g. curved 'springblades'
e.g. 2001-2007 attempts; 2013-2015 Adidas SPRINGBLADE) (poor performance)
Protracted adoption 2
Technologies that were initially opposed, but eventually succeeded (a control group of near-misses).
Health & medicine
Citrus juice against scurvy in the Royal Navy James Lind's citrus trial (1747) and the Royal Navy's lemon-juice ration (sanctioned 1795)
Lind's trial favoured citrus, but the Sick and Hurt Board rejected a fruit-juice proposal the year after his 1753 findings. The Admiralty sanctioned lemon juice in 1795, a 42-year lag; by 1815 scurvy had almost disappeared from the fleet (Wikipedia).
Biotechnology & synthetic biology
Engineered microorganisms for open environmental use
Environmental release of genetically engineered microbes in the US Engineered microorganisms for open environmental use. In 1986 US officials placed them under the 1976 Toxic Substances Control Act. Of more than 240 applications filed between 1987 and 2018, only a few were approved for wide use, partly because EPA never published its data requirements.
False first dawns 28
Technologies that had a ‘false dawn’, initially failing and then dwindling in obscurity for (often) decades, before they later found another opportunity and eventually gained more traction, in different circumstances.
Transport & land vehicles
Electric engines during the 19th century
And specifically the electric locomotive
Electric cars
- 1830s invention
- (in 1900, in the US and around the world, steam, internal combustion, and electric motors actually each powered a roughly equal number of automobiles; they were abandoned); another failed wave occurred in the 1990s (GM EV1)
Civil aircraft
Stratocruiser-based outsized cargo aircraft Aero Spacelines six-engine Super Guppy
Aero Spacelines concept, circa 1968, for a oversize six-engine variant of the Super Guppy to carry 747 components from Wichita, Kansas, to Everett, Washington. It did not come to pass; some thirty years later Boeing instead modified a 747 to carry 787 components.
Propfans for aircraft propulsion
(highly fuel-efficient, although noisy) were explored in the 1980s, and successfully tested; but lower fuel prices made the savings less critical; they have seen renewed interests in recent years, with targets for 2030s-2040s commercial flight
Military aircraft
Carrier-borne stealth bombers A-12 Avenger II; F-117N Seahawk
(cancelled after USD 2bn spent out of a USD 5bn program); F-117 Nighthawks adapted for carriers (F-117N Seahawk), allegedly because of the Navy's institutional preference for an 'ideal' (if delayed) program over re-configured available platforms: only a generation later, in 2019, did the stealth-capable F-35C get deployed on carriers
In-flight refuelling techniques
VTOL aircraft using a tilt-rotor design
It took 70 years across numerous rejected proposals and abandoned attempts, because of inadequate financial backing, the onset of WWII, contingent accidents, and institutional opposition, before reaching limited mass production with the V-22 Osprey after three contested decades, which continues to have a mixed safety record.
Civil space systems & space exploration
Recoverable & reusable first-stage booster rockets Saturn V S-IC stage recovery
Boeing's 1960s concept for recovering NASA's Saturn V S-IC first stage: large fins with drag brakes to hold it nose-down, parachutes, and retro rockets for terminal braking before splashdown, followed by refurbishment. Concept only; later revisited differently by SpaceX's Falcon 9.
Flyback rocket boosters
Super-heavy-lift launch vehicles
Rockets that can lift a payload of 50 metric tons (US) or 100 metric tons (Russia); while pursued since the 1960s, many programs ended in disaster. Only 14 such payloads were successfully launched before 2022 (however, this may be more consistently achieved by the Falcon Heavy)
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Ground-based midcourse strategic ballistic missile defence
(e.g. Project Safeguard became operational in September 1975, and almost immediately shut down by Congress; the US would not field another ABM system until 2002, which continues to have a highly mixed test success rate (55%)).
Other weapons & military systems
Tactical laser cannon used for counter-artillery fire
Energy
1890s simplified (two-stroke) internal combustion engines
Wind power
Magnetohydrodynamic generators arguably
Off-Grid Compressed Air Energy Storage
Small-scale compressed air storage (CAES), notably low-pressure near-isothermal designs, which have been proposed as a long-lived, low-maintenance alternative to chemical batteries for off-grid energy storage. Still early-stage research with experimental setups and no commercial products.
Computing, digital & communications
Videocalls 1964 Picturephone by AT&T
Smart glasses offering a permanent heads-up display arguably e.g. Google Glass
Google Wave
(2009-2010) a federated, real-time, operational-transform (OT) collaboration stack, that allowed real-time collaboration with seamless conversations in the document. However, the service was too ambitious, hard to learn, and ugly. (some features have been adopted since in other apps, such as Google Docs; but no others offer open federation with edits synchronized and conflict-resolved using OT).
Home automation
e.g. 1950s home relay lighting systems and 1980s Lutron Lumi 5
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Panama Canal initial failed attempt by Ferdinand de Lessep
Electric lighthouses
'Beginning in 1859, the lighthouse was the site of the first commercial application of generator-powered electric-arc lighting. At the end of the century, however, only about thirty had been installed among thousands of lighthouses worldwide.'
Agriculture
Electric ploughs and tractors Germany, pre-1914
Health & medicine
GPL-1 class of drugs for diabetes and obesity
Numerous modern biotech companies
Fundamental science
Large groundbased telescope arrays
Organizational & social technologies
Prediction markets
However: see this discussion of 17th-century 'prediction markets'
Consumer products & novelties
Injection-moulded plastic bicycles Itera
('Itera'); 1970s–80s injection-moulded designs such as the Itera failed commercially; though reinforced plastic composites are today used in racing bicycle frames and wheels)
Forlorn prototypes 98
Technologies that reached a functioning prototype, before being scrapped, never seeing full production and use.
Transport & land vehicles
Railplanes suspended trains utilizing lifting planes
Numerous 20th-century approaches to high-speed rail trains
Propellor-driven trains (e.g. 'rail Zeppelin'); turbojet trains; jet-powered hovertrains (abandoned for the TGV in 1974, as French President d'Estaing's wife had family interests in the conventional railroad and steel industry); ball-bearing electric-through trains (e.g. 'Sharopoyezd') running on a concave rail made of concrete
Dymaxion cars
With an extremely tight turn radius
Automotive gas turbine engines
Walking trucks or tractors
Modular (platooning-based) urban guided-transportation systems
Folding urban cars
To be stacked at transit hubs in a shared-use model
Gyroscopically stabilised two-wheeled car Shilovsky / Brennan gyrocars
Two-wheeled automobiles balanced by gyroscopes: Shilovsky's 1914 prototype (2.75 tons, very large turning radius) and Brennan's 1927 car with two contra-rotating gyros.
Light-emitting tires Goodyear illuminated tires (1961)
Goodyear's early-1960s translucent, dyed Neothane polyurethane tires, lit by 18 small bulbs in the rims and usable as turn signals or brake lights. Tested but abandoned: they skidded in wet weather, melted under heavy braking, and proved too expensive to produce commercially.
Civil aircraft
Ornithopters aircraft propelled by flapping-wings
Rotating-wing-propulsion aircraft utilizing the Magnus effect to produce lift
Steam-powered aircraft
Inflatable aircraft
All-terrain
(i.e. runway-free) airplanes (e.g. Soviet Bella-1)
'Flying saucer' aircraft utilizing the Coandă effect
Flying plank home-assembled tailless gliders
Half-barrel / 'channel' wings CCW-1 and CCW-2
Enabling extremely short take-off, but which failed federal certification requirements
Check note NASA research indicated the lift and field-length gains did not offset deficiencies in climb and high-speed ability and identified problems meeting general-aviation certification requirements; interested firms did not provide the necessary downpayment for CCW-5 production.
(low-width, easily storable) parasol-wing aircraft
Lifting-fuselage airliners
(e.g. 'Burnelli designs') non-cylindrical unswept-wing aircraft, supposedly offering aerodynamic advantages and (alleged) improved crash safety - one example retired, many other proposals unbuilt. However, aerodynamic advantage was limited, and pressurization was difficult to achieve
Civilian vertical/short takeoff and landing (V/STOL) aircraft
Such as regular autogyros or compound gyroplanes, or ramjet helicopters (using tip jets in their rotor blades, rather than axial engines, to spin their blades)
Distributed electric propulsion wings for fully electric aircraft
Modular aircraft with removable cargo pods e.g. Miles M.68; Fairchild Packplane
Super-heavy flying boats
Oblique- and pivoting-wing aircraft
Apparently cancelled despite being perfectly functional for supersonic flight, delivering up to twice the fuel economy of a traditional wing
Military aircraft
Forward-swept-wing fighters Grumman X-29
Forward-swept wings (1980s NASA X-29, Russia's Su-47, the Hansa Jet): better stall behaviour and lower induced drag, but lift twists the wing further (aeroelastic divergence), so they need very stiff or aeroelastically tailored materials (e.g. carbon-fibre).
'Helicopter Plane' hybrid rotorcraft Kamov Ka-22 & KA-35
Experimental Soviet transport aircraft with rotors above the wing tips, combining helicopter take-off with fixed-wing cruise; it set eight world records but was abandoned after two fatal crashes (1962, 1964) linked to control problems, with the Mi-6 helicopter already filling the heavy-helicopter role. See also video on the Soviet hybrid helicopter-plane lineage
Annular-wing tail-sitter VTOL aircraft SNECMA Coléoptère / Hiller VXT-8
Annular-wing tail-sitter VTOL (coleopter). The SNECMA Coléoptère first flew in May 1959 and crashed on a test flight that July; no replacement was built. Hiller's US VXT-8 reached only a mock-up, the Navy losing interest as turbine helicopters improved.
Military airships
(limited US use, many vessels lost in accidents (however, nearly half of all 162 rigid airships built served with the German Navy in WW1)
Flying aircraft carriers of WWII and the 1950s
Flying tanks
Modular-swap container transport aircraft Fi 333
Supersonic seaplanes
Amphibious
Sea-based strategic bombers (e.g. P6M SeaMaster)
'Tailsitter' interceptor aircraft for protection of areas without airfields
VTOL aircraft using ducted lift fans
e.g. XV-5 Vertifan, abandoned after crashes unrelated to the lift system
Supersonic VTOL aircraft using 'thrust augmented wings' XV-4, XFV-12
i.e. directing exhaust through spaces in a wing opened up like venetian blinds
Mixed jet-and-rocket propulsion interceptor aircraft
Comanche stealth helicopter program
Cancelled in 2004 after USD 7.9bn$ spent, just before the first units would roll off the production line (see also LHX program)
Civil space systems & space exploration
Fully Automated Luxury Space... shuttle USSR
Asteroid colonisation, mining & mass-driver propulsion Cole & Cox, Islands in Space, 1964
Numerous proposals for hollowed-asteroid habitats (e.g. Cole and Cox's 'Islands in Space').
Military space systems
Soviet armed military space station
(Almaz only test-fired once by the USSR
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Air-launched (i.e. more stealthy) anti-satellite missiles ASM-135 ASAT, launched by F-15
Air-launched anti-satellite missile carried by USAF F-15s; destroyed the Solwind P78-1 satellite in a September 1985 test. Congress banned tests against space targets in December 1985, and the Reagan Administration cancelled the program in 1988 over technical problems, testing delays and cost growth.
ICBM anti-missile defense systems based on a "wall of rods" shotgun Soviet Mozyr ABM system
Mozyr: Soviet lowest-echelon defense of ICBM silos, developed from the early 1980s by Kolomna's KBM design bureau: four 500-barrel assemblies firing coherent streams of tungsten rod elements at incoming warheads. Tested from 1987 at DEEP-1, downing a warhead; discussed for revival in 2022.
50-megaton nuclear warheads Tsar Bomba tested, but never deployed
Nuclear shaped charges
Nuclear weapons that focus their energy into certain directions; Teller's 'third-generation nuclear weapons' (after the atom bomb and H-bomb); only a single known test in 1985
Nuclear-powered ramjet engines
Allowing indefinite-range, perpetual-flight aircraft or cruise missiles
US proposals for the survivable basing of ICBMs based on rail networks …
US proposals for the survivable basing of ICBMs based on rail networks or deployed on road-mobile transporter-erector-launcher vehicles (e.g. 'Hard Mobile Launcher'), amongst other proposals
Boost-phase ballistic missile defense using aircraft-mounted lasers
Air-launched anti-satelite missiles (ASAT) e.g. Bold Orion
Naval (military)
Heavy-artillery-armed cruiser submarines and 'submarine monitors'
Submarine aircraft carriers
Limited deployment by Imperial Japan (I-400 class)
Ultra-large battleships
Anti-submarine 'floppy magnet' bombs
Air-dropped over the sea, intended to attach to submarines and bang against their hull, giving away their location; proved too effective, as NATO struggled to remove them from its own submarines after practice exercises
Civil maritime
Winans 'cigar ships' 1858-1866
Spindle-hulled cylindrical-hull ships with midship propellors (design principles eventually vindicated in submarines)
Disc-wheeled ship Bazin roller ship, 1896
Ernest Bazin's roller ship, a vessel propelled by large rotating discs. One 280-ton prototype was launched in 1896 and found unworkable in early 1897, because water adhering to the discs braked their rotation and raised fuel use.
Roller boats
Cylindrical ship, with a rotating outer shell while an inner shell remains stationary and level
(anti-blockade) merchant submarines
Ships using magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) thrusters
As extremely silent thrusters (originally proposed in the 1960s, only subject to new DARPA grants recently)
Very large floating structure VLSF
Kilometre-scale offshore floating platforms, using pontoons or semi-submersible floats, for airports or offshore cities (e.g. 1995-2001 Yokosuka Mega-Float runway)
Other weapons & military systems
Death rays imperial Japan, UK, Nazi Germany
Lobber
Convair battlefield cargo resupply system using a small tactical ballistic missile ('Dynamic Delivery')
Automated trench-digging machines
Tricycle tanks using giant wheels rather than caterpillar tracks to distribute weight
Personally funded by tsar Nicholas II in 1915, but sank into the ground on its first test
Ball tanks
Only one surviving vehicle built by Nazi Germany
Super-heavy tanks
Laser tanks
Bulk-loaded liquid propellants
Standardized artillery shells with varying propellant loads, improving accuracy and logistical and tactical flexibility
Giant radiation-hardened pilot-operated mecha/manipulator robots used for hazardous environment maintenance
Numerous types of non-lethal incapacitating weapons
Including directed sound energy devices; microwaves; high-intensity laser light-flashes, olfactory devices; hallucination-inducing 'psychomimetic' chemical agents; various drug weapons
Smart infantry armour
Incorporating integrated rangefinders, suit heating systems, microwave sensing devices to detect landmines
Large ground-based 'space guns' used as very-long-range artillery systems
Cosmonaut laser pistols
Coilguns
Electromagnetic projectile coil accelerators ('EM mass drivers'); a century of prototypes that have never displaced powder guns, mostly due to capacitor density, switching losses, and mass.
Electronically-fired stacked-projectile gun
(e.g. 'Metal Storm') system, with multiple projectiles stacked in a single barrel; capable of firing millions of rounds per minute
Aerial gunship-mounted tactical laser weapon
('long-range blow torch'), to provide a 'deniable' weapon with tactical range of 20 km (discontinued after succesful tests)
Robotic pack animals Big-dog, alphadog, ls3
Powered exoskeletons
Rocket boots
Piston boots that detonate fuel-air mixtures to launch a runner forward at more than 22 miles per hour
Self-healing minefields potentially; unsure about current status
Robotic anti-tank landmines that 'hop' around to re-organize and close breaches
Surveillance, intelligence & espionage
Psychological warfare using foxes spray-painted with radioactive glowing paint
"To find out whether the faux-supernatural foxes would actually frighten the Japanese, the OSS decided to release 30 glowing foxes in Washington, D.C.’s Rock Creek Park to gauge the reactions of the locals. If the foxes spooked Americans, the logic went, certainly they would scare the Japanese even more."
Animal-based surveillance by implanting microphones into cats Acoustic Kitty
Bird-camouflaged unmanned aerial spy vehicles
Large group of national-technical verification means
(e.g. particle detectors) developed by US nuclear labs, which weren't taken up (incl by international organizations)
Energy
Mobile nuclear power plants
Using nuclear-powered land trains; truck-mounted nuclear power, along with many rejected attempts
Fusion power based on the underground detonation of hydrogen bombs
Contestable; technically feasible but not economical, and abandoned before learning curves could kick in
Many early molten-salt thorium nuclear power reactors
Computing, digital & communications
Low-line mechanical television
Czech invention, abandoned because of state authority red tape, political quarrels, and the political situation prior to World War II
Project Xanadu bidirectional hypertext alternative to the internet
Prediction markets for use in government intelligence analysis
Shut down after two years after US senators denounced it as '“terrorism betting parlors”, arguing that “(s)pending millions of dollars on some kind of fantasy league terror game is absurd and, frankly, ought to make every American angry.”'
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Dymaxion house 1929
Modular house, designed to be inexpensive as well as easy to build and maintain, but no company took an interest in manufacturing it. A full-scale prototype was built with U.S. government funding after WWII; but despite consumers eager to buy the house, it was not brought to market.
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
The Wisconsin Process for nitrogen fixation a non-high-pressure alternative to Haber ammonia synthesis
Rocket drills
(e.g. 'underground rocket'); Soviet rocket-propelled drilling device that used supersonic hot-gas jets from nozzles to break through rock at up to 1 m/s. Proposed in 1948; several prototypes were built and tested from 1968 onwards, but the device never went into production.
Biotechnology & synthetic biology
Transgenic pig Enviropig (phytase transgenic pig) created 1999, funding ended 2012
Guelph researchers made the first Enviropig in 1999, a transgenic pig engineered to produce less-polluting waste; the project cost over $5 million. In 2012 its main industry sponsor quit funding and the university said the herd might be euthanized (doi.org, 2001).
Environmental
Various strategic weather control projects
Including hurricane control by silver iodide seeding; and military cloud-seeding for extending local monsoons
Artificial ionosphere of millions of copper dipole antennas shot into orbit to facilitate robust military radio communications
US program for 'Peaceful Nuclear Explosions'
Use in 'geographical engineering'; including: US 1958 proposal to blast an artificial harbor in Alaska with five hydrogen bombs (Project Chariot, abandoned after local opposition and international criticism); 1960s proposal to use hundreds of nuclear detonations to blast an interoceanic canal through Colombia, abandoned in the face of expected local and international condemnation
Fully enclosed ecosystems technology critical to support human life in outer space
Consumer products & novelties
Smell-O-Vision systems that released odors during film projection
Development hell 50
Technologies that have seen sustained, continuous and costly attempts for development for decades, which (to date) have all failed. They differ from abandoned development in that there are still active programs.
Transport & land vehicles
US high-speed rail
''In The Second Age of Rail, author Murray Hughes notes that "so many proposals for high-speed railways in the USA have been dreamt up and shot down that it is almost unsporting to list them."
Carbon-fiber cars lightweight material for car bodies
Self-driving cars possible countercase
e.g. Quevedo demonstrated 'telekino', the first wireless control systems, in 1904 but Spanish Crown was reluctant to invest;...
Civil aircraft
Vacuum airships using evacuated metal or composite spheres rather than hot air or gas to create a lighter-than-air craft
Proposed by Francesco Lana de Terzi in 1670, and periodically revisited
Supersonic airliners
Flying cars or personal vertical takeoff air taxis e.g. Larry Page's 2010-2022 Kittyhawk project
Despite numerous attempts (in part because of regulatory burdens from FAA)
Civil VTOL aircraft that can efficiently hover yet also fly faster than conventional rotorcraft
Lighter-than-air heavy cargo airlifters/airships arguably
Numerous proposals in the 1970s and 1980s; 1990s German 'CargoLifter CL160 (853-ft 160-ton helium airship, bankrupted in 2002); CargoLifter today markets a small 'AirKules' for disaster relief operations, but unclear what is record of operations
Military aircraft
Aircraft capable of fluidic thrust vectoring (flapless flight control; steering without radar-exposing moving control surfaces) FLAVIIR / DEMON
FLAVIIR: £6.5 million UK programme (Cranfield, Manchester, BAE Systems) replacing radar-exposing control surfaces with blown Coanda-effect 'flaps' and fluidic thrust vectoring; its Demon drone was the first aircraft to fly without flaps. Demonstrators only so far: BAE's MAGMA drone (2019) and DARPA's X-65 CRANE followed.
Civil space systems & space exploration
Repeated proposals for civilian moon bases
Orbital factories offering in-space manufacturing (ISM) or industrial processing
Utilizing the prevailing microgravity and vacuum conditions for manufacturing materials impossible to produce on earth; pursued since the 1970s, but still unrealized
Crewed missions to Venus and/or Mars
Especially by private or nonprofit actors
Private commercial space stations
Numerous proposals for an orbiting laser broom
Pulsed lasers to ablate small orbital debris and nudge it into re-entry, mitigating Kessler syndrome; NASA's 1996 Project Orion proposal estimated $500M to clear all sub-10 cm debris below 1100 km within two years. Never progressed.
Orbital mirror satellites for nighttime illumination of cities
Several proposals and attempts: (1) in the 1970s, Rockwell proposed 'Lunetta', a scheme for vast orbiting reflectors to illuminate cities at night and boost solar power, impractical at the required orbital construction scale (see also NYT, 1977); (2) in the *Znamya* experiments, the Russian federation actually deployed a orbital space mirror in a test that could reportedly be observed from Earth, though the project was abandoned after the failure of the second test; (3) as of 2026, Reflect Orbital got a license from the Federal Communications Commission to launch a test satellite.
Numerous attempts at creating single-stage-to-orbit (SSTO) spacecraft
Cryogenic propellant management in space
(e.g. orbital refueling infrastructure, including transfer to spacecraft).
Space elevators
Wireless space-based solar power farms
Using space mirrors, lasers or microwave to beam power down to earth; despite six decades of studies no demonstrator has flown
Free-floating cylindrical or inflatable rotating space habitats with artificial gravity
Suitable for longer-term habitation by larger populations
Military space systems
Neutral particle beam satellite weapons
Many possible designs pursued by the Strategic Defense Initiative Organization in the 1980s, but abandoned by 1993 (after USD 794 million spent); the idea was last (briefly) revived in 2019
Civil maritime
Numerous attempts at seasteading and floating cities
Other weapons & military systems
Stealth tanks
(e.g. using ADAPTIV active camouflage); some trial systems with lower radar signatures
'Supersuit' tactical exoskeleton & armour suits arguably
Guided-lightning weapons
e.g. electrolasers
Vehicle-mounted high-energy laser weapons possible countercase
Currently numerous vehicle-mounted directed energy weapons, including on U.S. Navy destroyers, primarily in anti-drone roles
Energy
Fusion power
Buoyancy-driven solar chimneys / solar updraft towers generating electricity from convection from hot updraft
Land-intensive. A Spanish 1982 prototype achieved only 50 kW peak at ~2% efficiency before collapsing in a 1989 storm.
Supercritical light-water reactors
Direct-drive tidal-current turbines e.g. OpenHydro freestream turbines
A highly predictable renewable energy source crushed by water density, biofouling, and impossible maintenance access.
Wave energy converter programs various attempts at least since the 1890s
Hot dry rock geothermal energy
Ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) renewable energy technology arguably
Harnessing the temperature difference between warm surface waters and cold depths to run a heat engine
Wave energy converters
Wave energy converters in many forms: Islay's Limpet (250 kW, 2000–2011), Denmark's Wave Dragon (2003–2010), Aquamarine's Oyster, and Pelamis, whose Portuguese farm was wrecked by weather. Machines must be able to survive hundred-year storms, so costs stay high.
Computing, digital & communications
Holographic data storage
Volumetric display devices
'True 3D' displays, that create a visual representation of an object in three dimensions rather than a simulation of depth on planar images
AGI using symbolic approaches e.g. Cyc
Expert system software (e.g. Fifth Generation Computer Systems; SCI)
Room-temperature superconductors
e.g. notable cases such as LK-99 did not survive global replication; though the search continues
Molecular nanotechnology / atomically precise nanotechnology
Using programmable tools to position single atoms and create specific chemical bonds in order to build larger structures from the ground up. E.g. in his 1959 lecture 'There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom', Richard Feynman predicted this was an inevitability: '"in the year 2000, when they look back at this age, they will wonder why it was not until the year 1960 that anybody began seriously to move in this direction."'; this appeared to be set for serious governmental funding in the early 2000s; however, following the Drexler-Smalley debate in the early 2000s, innovation in nanotechnology field steered away from this direction, focusing more on piecemeal applications at the higher end of the nanotechnology scale, with near-term applications like nanomaterials, rather than general tools like molecular manufacturing.
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Repeated attempts 1947, 1967, 2015
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
Von Neumann universal constructors arguably e.g. fully self-replicating 3D printers
Agriculture
Nitrogen-fixing cereals crops without a need for nitrogen from chemical fertilizers
Health & medicine
Artificial blood synthetic blood substitutes
Strep A vaccines
A disease that is responsible for 518,000 deaths annually, but primarily in low- and middle-income countries
Syphilis vaccine
Universal flu vaccine providing broad
Long-lasting protection across influenza strains
Many types of exoskeletons arguably
Organizational & social technologies
Universal (digital) library
e.g. 'Alexandria in the cloud'; Google Books, blocked by copyright law
Universally recognizable pictographic language
e.g. ISOTYPE
Consumer products & novelties
Artificial gills
Abandoned development 73
Technologies that were researched and developed, sometimes at very large sunk costs, before being abandoned for reasons ranging from the technical to the political to budgetary.
Civil aircraft
'Transonic' commercial airliners
Airliners capable of high cruising speeds, at mach 0.98, without breaking the sound barrier
Airliners and air freighters flying on liquid hydrogen
Feasible, but would have required refit of existing airport refuelling infrastructure and crew training
Numerous proposed second-generation supersonic transport aircraft
Including proposals that would use cryogenic fuel for increased range (USSR Tu-244), 'boomless' flight (SAI Quiet Supersonic Transport), or aircraft specific to business customers (e.g. Aerion SBJ)
- (though renewed in X-59 Quesst)
Hybrid lifting-body cargo airship
(e.g. 'Aereon Dynairship' delta-shape hybrid for 3,300+ tons, never funded; the DoD reportedly told designers in 2003 they were "30 years ahead of... time."
Military aircraft
Various proposals and programs for an 'antipodal bomber'
(i.e. space bombers; sub-orbital bomber) spaceplanes (e.g. Silbervogel, Keldysh bomber), abandoned at various stages
Nuclear-powered aircraft
Pursued by both US and Soviets, though ran into significant radiation-shielding weight problems (and crash safety concerns); US spent over $1 billion in a decade
Submersible seaplanes
VTOL through 'stopped-rotor convertiplanes' such as 1980s 'X-Wing' vehicles
Helicopters with rigid four-bladed rotors that could stop in flight and then serve as wings
US civilian supersonic airplane transport (SST) projects
Supersonic VTOL aircraft
Convertible flying tanks/tailsitter barrel gunships for close air support
Long-range strategic airlift using hybrid (heavier-than-air but engine-assisted) airships
Floating aerostat radars
High-altitude airship using the entire hull as radar aperture for across-the-horizon radar tracking
Civil-transport heavy helicopter Hughes Helibus
Early-1960s Hughes concept for a hot-cycle 'Helibus': rotors driven by turbojet exhaust, no tail rotor, a door for each row of seats.
Liquid-hydrogen military airlifter LH2 C-141
Lockheed 1970s study of a liquid-hydrogen version of the C-141, with vast wingtip fuel tanks, done within wider US alternate-fuel studies.
Civil space systems & space exploration
Spacecraft propulsion using nuclear thermal rocket engines
Interstellar probes using laser-powered light-sail propulsion
Second US spacestation
A much more ambitious version of the International Space Station
'Space tug'
Symmetrical multi-stage rockets
(e.g. Convair or General Dynamics 'triamese'; BAC MUSTARD) utilizing joined-together identical spaceplanes, two functioning as flyback boosters and one as orbiter, envisioned to be 20-30x cheaper than Apollo
Space Shuttle 'beam builders'
Deployable mechanisms to automatically bend, deploy, and weld rolls of aluminum tape into truss structure beams for large-scale space station construction
Numerous Space Shuttle upgrades
Expansions, and replacements, including: uncrewed reusable cargo launchers ('Shuttle C'), group passenger-carrying Shuttle variant
Air-launched reusable orbiter spaceplanes i.e. launching spaceplanes from atop aircraft
Spaceship-steerable re-entry systems
(rather than unsteerable parachutes) by using paraglider wings or unfolding helicopter (autogyro) rotors
Manned space missions to Mars and Venus
Private moon colonization and exploitation using leftover Saturn rockets and modules
Ground-based space guns for orbital delivery e.g. 'Verne guns'
Check note space guns have never successfully launched an object into orbit. Project HARP's guns reached about 180 km on suborbital flights, and its planned orbital vehicle, the Martlet 4, was never built before the programme was cancelled.
Crewed cislunar (moon orbit) space stations
e.g. Lunar Gateway Station, elements constructed as part of the Artemis program, but 'paused' in 2026
Sea-launched super-heavy steel-shipyard rocket Robert Truax Sea Dragon, 1962
1962 Truax design study for a 150 m, two-stage, sea-launched rocket built of steel sheet in a shipyard, 550 t to LEO, validated by TRW; never built, as budget pressures closed the Future Projects Branch. (more generally: the 'big dumb booster' design-philosophy overview)
Feasibility analysis of small-asteroid retrieval Keck Institute Asteroid Retrieval Feasibility Study, 2012
Keck Institute for Space Studies (JPL) study concept for capturing a ~7 m near-Earth asteroid (250–1000 t) with a solar-electric spacecraft and inflatable bag, and moving it to lunar orbit by 2025.
In-orbit cryogenic propellant storage Orbital propellant depot
1963 General Dynamics concept for a toroidal orbital propellant depot, supplied from Earth to fuel Mars-type missions and packed into spare payload space on a Nova launch vehicle. Concept only.
Military space systems
Atomic space battleships battleships using nuclear pulse propulsion
(for nuclear bombardment and/or Mars space missions); 1958-1965 Project Orion was cancelled in Jan 1965 by the Limited Test Ban Treaty, which banned atmospheric nuclear detonations (Freeman Dyson wrote: "The story of Orion is important, because this is the first time in modern history that a major expansion of human technology has been suppressed for political reasons").
US military space station Manned Orbiting Laboratory cancelled in 1969
One-man space stations / piloted spy satelites
Repeated proposals to deploy the Marines via Intercontinental Ballistic Missile
Small and cheap 'stealth satellite launch' capability
Using small launch vehicles carried by F-15 fighter jets (abandoned over safety concerns with the propellant)
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
1950s project to nuke the moon intended propaganda victory
US 50-100 megaton hydrogen bomb Flashback
Soviet >100 megaton nuclear warheads planned yield of Tsar Bomba
Basing of nuclear missiles under the Greenland ice sheet Project Iceworm
600 ICBMs based in 4,000 km of Greenland ice tunnels; defeated by viscoelastic ice creep.
Super-heavy ICBMs with throw weight of 20-30+ tonnes
Capable of delivering 100-megaton yield warheads. Khrushchev reportedly asked 'what should we build - communism or silos for the UR-500?'. Though note: the ICBM proposal was abandoned around 1964, and the UR-500 reworked into the civilian space-launch vehicle Proton; heavy ICBMs were later developed by the USSR, though by the different Yangel design bureau; but their throw-weight (10 tonnes) never equalled the envisioned one.
Various nuclear warhead delivery systems in the USSR and/or US
Space-based midcourse strategic anti-ballistic missile defense numerous programs, e.g. Zenith Star, Skif-DM, Prometheus, Casaba-Howitzer, BAMBI, Smart Rocks and Brilliant Pebbles
Involving, amongst others:
- Orbital missile platforms
- Orbital chemical laserbattle stations ('Zenith Star'; mocked up at full scale)
- Nuclear-bomb-powered X-ray lasers
- Directed-energy weapons
- Swarms of small, rocket-powered kinetic impactor satellites or interceptors dragging wire webs
- Hypervelocity railguns
- Shaped-charge 'nuclear shotguns', using hydrogen bombs to project plasma beams (e.g. Casaba-Howitzer' concepts), or kinetic impactors (Project Prometheus) towards a target
Phased-array nuclear-tipped ABM systems Nike Zeus / Nike-X / Sentinel / Safeguard
Chain of US Army ABM programs cancelled or shut down due to overwhelming cost and easy decoy defeat (Safeguard ran one day in 1976).
Check note US Army phased-array anti-ballistic missile system of the 1960s, evolved from Nike Zeus. Cancelled in 1967 and replaced by the lighter Sentinel because of huge projected cost and vulnerability to decoys and attack saturation.
Airborne laser weapons cancelled
US Air Force halting its push for an airborne high-energy laser (SHiELD) to defend aircraft against drones and missiles, per July 2025 budget documents, for the second year in a row. The latest entry in a long airborne-laser cancellation lineage (cf. the YAL-1 Airborne Laser)
Biological & chemical weapons
'Death dust' radiological weapons
Abandoned by all states, even after coordinated arms control efforts had failed
Anti-machinery biological weapons using corrosive bacterial strains such as Pseudomonas mallei
'Chimera' biological weapons incorporating genetic components from different pathogens
Psychochemical weapons USSR
Naval (military)
Bergships
Massive, functionally unsinkable aircraft carriers twice the size of modern supercarriers, constructed out of a pykrete (wood pulp/iceberg mix) (Project Habakkuk, abandoned not because of technical infeasibility, but because of strategic changes)
Nuclear-powered amphibious assault ships
16-inch naval gunfire support Iowa-class retirement / ERGM / DD-21 / Zumwalt
1992–2011 US debate over retiring the Iowa-class battleships and replacing their 16-inch naval gunfire support. ERGM was cancelled in 2008 and Zumwalt procurement was cut to three ships. The debate ended when Iowa became a museum ship in 2011.
Surface ship as ballistic-missile platform USS Long Beach with Polaris
A 1961 design for the Long Beach-class cruiser launching a Polaris missile. The Navy judged surface ships easier to spot and track than stealthier submarines, so strategic missiles went on submarines.
Other weapons & military systems
Hovercraft tanks
Nuclear-powered amphibious tanks e.g. Chrysler TV-8
Bipedal combat mechs and 'mechanical elephants' for use in Vietnam
'It is alleged that when the director heard of the plan he scrapped the "damn fool" project immediately in the hope no one would hear about it.' - source
(permanently) blinding laser weapons and rifles
Pigeon-guided glide bombs
Flying jeeps / Humvees intended to avoid IEDs
Next generation infantry assault rifles using airburst munition
Giant survivable extremely-low-frequency antenna arrays (over 22,500 square miles) for communication to nuclear submarines arguable
Hypersonic anti-tank kinetic energy missiles
Artillery cannon capable of firing 1,000 miles e.g. from Southern Germany to Moscow
Using rocket-assisted shells
Crowd-sourced and open-source design process for military combat vehicles status unsure
US Army tactical helmet-mounted display IVAS / HoloLens 2 / Anduril EagleEye
Roughly 35 years of failed US military attempts to build a tactical helmet-mounted display, including a $22B HoloLens-based program plagued by cybersickness and software glitches. Recently followed by Anduril's EagleEye (unveiled Oct 2025).
Surveillance, intelligence & espionage
Insectothopter miniature unmanned aerial vehicle disquised as a dragonfly
Cybernetic, remotely-controlled insects for inspecting explosives
Energy
Microchip-sized nuclear fusion reactors
Computing, digital & communications
Lisp-optimised workstations Symbolics Lisp Machines
Symbolics Lisp machines: single-user computers with a special hardware-tagged Lisp architecture, sold commercially. They lost out as Unix workstations ran Lisp well enough on cheaper hardware, the AI winter hit around 1988, and management conflicts and costly leases drained the company.
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Nuclear-thermal tunnel-boring machines or vehicles e.g. 'atomic subterrene'
Machines using nuclear reactor heat to melt rock and provide extensive tunnelling ability
Health & medicine
Amyloid-cascade-dominant Alzheimer's research
Amyloid cascade hypothesis-driven Alzheimer's research, built on the PDAPP transgenic mouse. Elan sponsored four failed amyloid-based therapeutics costing $2 billion before becoming defunct in 2013.
Environmental
Various geoengineering techniques and their delivery systems
Fundamental science
US's Superconducting Super Collider significantly larger than the LHC
Consumer products & novelties
Modular smartphones
Dead ends and science fictions 18
Technologies that were (once or even today) fervently pursued and sincerely expected, but which elude us to date, because they are based on scientific assumptions that are today overwhelmingly held to be incorrect or implausible (e.g. they violate the known laws of physics, or their main mechanisms have never been observed).
Civil space systems & space exploration
Warp drives e.g. Alcubierre drive
Gravity propulsion i.e. anti-gravity
Various proposals for reactionless drives
Producing spacecraft motion without exhaust of propellant, in a closed system; e.g. Dean drive, Helical engine, EmDrive;...
(arguably) Bussard ramjets for interstellar propulsion
Compressing hydrogen scooped up from the interstellar medium for fuel
Crewed interstellar space travel debatably
Barring fundamental scientific breakthroughs, crewed interstellar space travel is likely impossible; most depictions in popular culture invoke engine jump mechanisms that would violate known laws of physics (warp drives, hyperspace or wormhole travel), or are sociologically highly implausible and fragile (e.g. generation ships) (see also Scientific American; Stross, 'The myth of the Starship')
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Program for missile defense using 1,000 equatorially mounted Atlas rocket engines alleged
To briefly slow the Earth's rotation, making all incoming missiles miss (US Air Force 'Project Retro', alleged by Ellsberg)
Biological & chemical weapons
'Gay Bomb'
Theoretical non-lethal psychochemical weapon proposed in 1994 by the U.S. Air Force, which envisioned dispersing strong aphrodisiacs and female sex pheromones over enemy forces to destroy unit cohesion. Based on deeply flawed science, it was nonetheless part of a 2002 grant proposal for $7.5 million to pursue development, though it was apparently dismissed.
Genetically / ethnically targetable bioweapons
In spite of repeated (though unvalidated) accusations that some actors have conducted research programs, this is likely not very feasible, given only a limited number of genetic variants with a role in modulating infection which could be used as a basis for ethnic targeting
Other weapons & military systems
Nikola Tesla's 'telautomatic' tidal wave weapon
As well as 'Teleforce', his 1930s announcement of a particle beam weapon shooting slugs via electrostatic repulsion
Hafnium isomer bombs
Surveillance, intelligence & espionage
Psychic and telephatic remote viewing for military intelligence
Initiated after a 1973 RAND Corporation report examining Soviet "advances" in the fields of telepathy, precognition, telekinesis and dermo-optics (the "dermal sensing of visual information")"
Energy
Nikola Tesla's World System
Proposal for worldwide wireless energy and information, sent out by arrays of towers
Energy from cold fusion experiments revived by Google in 2015
'Free energy' from perpetual motion machines pursued for at least 1,400 years
Water-fuelled cars
A recurring fraud category since the 1970s in which inventors (Stan Meyer, Genesis World Energy, Genepax, etc.) claim engines that run on water as fuel.
Earth-resonance global power transmission Tesla Wardenclyffe Tower, 1901–1917
Tesla's 1901–02 Long Island wireless station using Earth resonance for transatlantic messaging and, in his scaled-up plan, wireless power. Tower built but never operational; J. P. Morgan refused funds for the enlarged design, the project was abandoned in 1906, and the tower demolished in 1917.
Industrial, manufacturing & materials
Polywater 1966-1971
Alleged Soviet discovery of a form of water with unique evaporative and freezing properties, prompting a rush by scientists to replicate, with many replications succeeding. 'After more than one hundred articles had been published, the disappointing truth came out. Polywater is normal water contaminated with the researchers' sweat.'
Agriculture
Lysenkoist-based agricultural practices
Crushed seeds 50
Technologies that were proposed, theorized, and/or considered, and appeared within the competence of the developing actor, but which were never ultimately funded or pursued.
Transport & land vehicles
1930s giant desert-crossing land ships
Nuclear-powered cars
Vactrain (Vacuum Tube Train) e.g. Planetran, Very High Speed Transit System, Hyperloop
Vehicles, mostly maglev, running through partially evacuated tubes, theoretically at up to 4,000 km/h (2,500 mph); proposed since 1906 and built as scale models since 1917, with test tracks (a 2 km line in China, 2023) but no working line.
- Including proposed applications for high-speed trans-continental transport. For instance, RAND in 1972 proposed the transcontinental Very High Speed Transit System ('RAND VHST / Salter, 1972'), developed by 1978 into Planetran (Salter 1978): carriages levitated and driven by electromagnetic fields in evacuated tunnels, coast to coast in 21 minutes at up to 14,000 mph; Salter put the high-speed network at $250 billion and judged politics harder than engineering. Never built.
Civil aircraft
'Flying wing' jetliners
Northrop YB-49 adaptation; see also source
Airline travel through an aerial relay system to reduce major hub airport congestion
i.e. a series of airline 'liners' continuously cruise at set altitudes and predetermined schedules, these are met by small 'feeder' aircraft carying aloft passengers, which dock in the liners and are fully carried along to their destination
Military aircraft
'Battleglider' troop transports
Large gliders relying on attached, detachable fighter planes for initial propulsion
Asymmetrical twin-fuselage bomber/plane carrier aircraft Douglas 1240
Asymmetrical twin-boom, twin-fuselage bomber/carrier aircraft (e.g. Douglas 1240)
Bomber aircraft with floating, detachable wingtip fuel tanks for significant range extension
Combination Aircraft e.g. Lockheed blackjack ws-125A
A nuclear-powered tug aircraft dragging around a conventional strike aircraft that is able to detach and dash into enemy airspace
Fighter aircraft with back-mounted upward-lifting bombs for very-low-altitude release
Heavy bombers launched from jet-assistedd railcarts using detachable auxiliary wings/fuel tanks
Fairchild M-121 (1948); considered too unconventional and killed by LeMay's backing for B-52
Giant nuclear-powered helicopters
Nuclear-powered loitering reconnaissance drones
Amphibious sea-based supersonic strategic bombers
(e.g. Bartini A-57, Myasishchev M-70; Convair Water-based B58) and attack aircraft
Flying aircraft carriers modern proposals for
Hypersonic spyplanes
Design studies for successors to the SR-71, capable of traveling at Mach 6. The studies were not linked to actual development, and the Air Force reportedly judged hypersonic technology too immature for a spyplane.
VTOL aircraft using augmentor-wings and air cushion landing systems Bell TAC VTOL
Bell 'TAC VTOL' concept, late 1960s or early 1970s: a heavily armed VTOL aircraft using augmenter technology for vertical thrust and an air cushion landing system, dating from Bell's push for such landing systems and before the augmenter-wing XFV-12's failure.
Modular hypersonic test plane Incremental Growth Vehicle
Early-1970s McDonnell-Douglas proposal for a manned hypersonic X-plane designed so major components could be replaced between experiments: a simple rocket vehicle first, then a stretched fuselage, new rocket engines, new wings, or airbreathing engines. Only a proposal.
Civil space systems & space exploration
Post-Apollo 'Nova' rocket for use in a Mars mission
Numerous proposals for crewed Mars space missions
Deep space interstellar probes that would travel one thousand astronomical units from the Earth over 50 years
To measure the distance to other stars via stellar parallax
Numerous NASA proposals for ambitious follow-ups to the Moon Landings e.g. NASA 1969 seminar 'After the Moon - What?'
Including spaceplane space shuttles; orbital transfer nuclear spaced shuttles; space tugs; by 1979, several permanent and modular space stations hosting 'several tens or even hundreds of people' in low earth, polar, and geosynchronous orbit; a reusable Mars mission architecture; in-orbit repair and satellite servicing and in-space refuelling architecture (see also source)
Rotating commercial space hotel Hilton/Ehricke Astropolis, 1967
Barron Hilton and Krafft Ehricke's 1967 design, later called Astropolis, for a rotating artificial-gravity orbital hotel for 1,100 guests. It assumed $10/lb launch costs.
Nuclear-powered orbital debris sweeper using a laser impulse device pg 23
Space Station for staging manned interplanetary missions 'Dual keel' orbital staging space station concept
A 1989 'dual keel' Space Station concept, with a partially enclosed hangar below and an aeroshell-equipped Mars vehicle above, intended as an assembly station and launch point for manned Moon and Mars missions, powered by photovoltaic arrays and solar dynamic generators. Concept only.
Military space systems
Military moon bases e.g. Project Horizon
Shelved by JFK who wanted to avoid militarization of space; later follow-ups barred by the 1967 Outer Space Treaty
Manned combat interceptor & satellite sabotage spacecraft for "covert space denial"
A 1964–65 Grumman study, later Navy-funded, of a modified Apollo Lunar Module to inspect and disable enemy satellites with a remote arm; more ambitious proposals included a 1963 manned space fighter concept, a variable-geometry combat spaceplane). Such interceptors were abandoned under SALT 1.
Raytheon proposals for 'Space Defense Platforms' armed with interceptor missiles
General Electric proposal for an orbital railgun the size of the International Space Station e.g. 'Have Sting'
Wernher von Braun's proposal for a manned 'space superiority' orbital battle station armed with nuclear missiles
Planetoid bombs
Proposal to manoeuvre asteroids with thrusters to support strategic deterrence
Orbital kinetic hypervelocity bombardment systems Rods from God
Orbital 'wheelguns'
Orbital weapons systems storing significant weapon energy in rotating flywheels
Rapid global transport and deployment of infantry with a capsule mounted on NASA's
(cancelled) Nova rocket
Rocket troop transport Douglas ICARUS / Ithacus
Douglas ICARUS/Ithacus: a 1960s concept for a rocket vehicle to transport 1200 Marines anywhere on Earth in 45 minutes.
Nuclear & strategic weapons, delivery systems & countermeasures
Gigaton-yield nuclear warheads 'continent killers', e.g. Projects GNOMON and SUNDIAL
Timed nuclear landmines
Numerous proposals for the survivable basing of ICBMs
Including ideas for basing them:
- At sea: on micro-submarines, in pods floating on the ocean surface; in 'seabed bottom launchers' in fixed silos anchored at the bottom of the ocean seabed, or on mobile ocean-floor crawler platforms; on large amphibious aircraft
- In the air: mounted under wide-body jets or slung under dirigibles
- On land: hidden in super-hard 'deep-underground bases' and subterranean tunnels (e.g. 1,200-1,500m down in bedrock); or in networks of (radar-opaque) pools of water; or on river-going ship barges
- On vehicles: mounted on 'Big Wheel' off-road monster trucks, modified assault hovercraft or purpose-built giant armored hovercraft
- In space: in orbit; secreted in missile bases on the moon; hidden in deep space
Numerous proposals for anti-satellite (ASAT) weapons
Including proposals focusing on: air-launched interceptors (1961–63)
- Soyuz-P (manned inspect-and-destroy) — rejected; EVA against a satellite presumed to have an automatic self-destruct was effectively suicide.
- Soyuz 7K-PPK (manned stand-off with rocket-mines) — dropped after Soyuz development delays and success of the unmanned kamikaze tests.
- Unmanned interceptor with mine-rockets — abandoned; same guidance-accuracy problem, plus the interceptor exposed itself to counter-ASATs during approach.
- Lurking on-orbit interceptors — paper only; needed an oversized engine/fuel load, ≤12-month storage life, and would themselves be ASAT targets.
- Multi-target mine dispenser (12 interceptors per launch) — rejected as prohibitively large and expensive despite optimal targeting economics.
Naval (military)
Giant amphibious invasion- & assault submarines
Submersible nuclear ramjets
Convair 1957-1961 study; manned high-speed submarine/aircraft hybrid, capable of launching itself out of the water and converting to airbreathing nuclear ramjet-powered flight
Deep-ocean 'rocksites'
e.g. completely independent manned stations in tunnels drilled below the seafloor, with sea-floor entry
Nuclear submarine carrying VTOL fighters AN-1 submarine aircraft carrier
Late-1950s US Navy design for a nuclear submarine based on the Halibut class, carrying eight Boeing Mach-3 tail-sitting VTOL fighters in internal hangars. The Navy lost interest, and it never left the drawing board.
Mobile offshore base MOB
1990s US Navy/DARPA concept for a kilometre-long modular floating sea base built from semi-submersible platforms that could be moved or towed together to form an airfield and logistics hub anywhere in the world; "the largest floating offshore structure ever conceived by maritime engineers". Studies in the late 90's concluded it was technically feasible and could be built by the US defense industry, at a full cost (for a 2km long MOB) $5–8 billion.
Civil maritime
Sub-arctic LNG tanker submarines
Other weapons & military systems
Nondetectable fragmenting (glass or plastic) bullets that leave fragments that are harder …
Nondetectable fragmenting (glass or plastic) bullets that leave fragments that are harder to detect by X-ray and remove surgically. Banned by Protocol I to the 1980 Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, but widely considered that this was an anticipatory ban on a 'phantom weapon' that no state had seriously decided to pursue
Space-capable firearms
1965 US Army Weapons Command study of conventional, gas, spring, and rocket weapons capable of operating in vacuum, low gravity, and suitable for space-suit handling, for use on lunar or space-based infantry combat.
Computing, digital & communications
Roll-away computer
('Toshiba DynaSheet'), a 2000 Toshiba forecast for a 1 mm thick, ~200 g rollable polymer-display computer
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Domed climate-controlled towns 1979 'Winooski Dome'
A TVA-validated proposal by a Vermont mill town City Council, aimed at covering the town with a transparent vinyl dome to achieve 90% heating-cost-reduction. Study assessed it would be 'financially feasible if home heating fuel hit $1 per gallon'. Allegedly killed by White House political pressure.
Environmental
Weather control projects based on nuking hurricanes
Performative proposals 20
Technological ideas that were (likely) not presented seriously, but rather for their PR value. Such proposals are meant more to signal something about their originators, or express a vision, or shape the culture or public perceptions of other technologies (or technology generally), rather than actually being intended for development.
Civil aircraft
American Flying City
A 1950s 'Atoms for Peace' nuclear-powered airship, acting as traveling world fair - (see also source)
Sky Cruise
A modern nuclear-powered flying aircraft capable of accommodating 5,000 guests
Civil space systems & space exploration
Interstellar spacecraft
e.g. Enzmann starships using a ball of frozen deuterium to fuel nuclear pulse engines; Daedalus probes using fusion rockets
Giant torus space stations hosting several thousand permanent inhabitants
(e.g. NASA design studies; O'Neill Space Cylinder orbital space settlements; 'Island One' Bernal sphere; Grumman 1960s proposals for large rotating space stations); in some cases, these were implicitly intended as sacrificial lambs, designed to take the heat under anticipated budgetary pressure or scrutiny
Mining the Martian moons Phobos and Deimos using a nuclear-powered space mining complex flown from low earth orbit pg 71
Multigenerational interstellar generation ship e.g. 'Tsiolkovsky/Bernal World Ship'
World ship: a multigenerational interstellar vehicle concept, carrying thousands of people across centuries. Ever larger, more ambitious designs, including McKendree's 1996 diamondoid-material space colonies. Only a conceptual proposal. A 2012 analysis suggests that world ships require a prior solar-system-spanning space civilisation before they become feasible.
Military space systems
Nazi Sonnengewehr
(heliobeam / sun gun) orbital weapon (though this is likely based on a misunderstanding.
Near-space 'aerospace carrier' ship AVIC Luanniao "Nantianmen Project"
A 242-m, 120,000-ton near-space "aerospace carrier" launching smaller aircraft, the centrepiece of the Nantianmen Project, an aviation futures imagining programme run since 2017 through videos, concept art and full-scale mock-ups; none of it has been demonstrated (Center for China Analysis 2026).
Naval (military)
'Trump-class battleship'
Proposed nuclear-powered, guided-missile warship armed with nuclear-armed cruise missiles, hypersonic missiles, railguns, and laser cannons, along with a hangar for VTOL aircraft. Widely considered a fledgling vanity project that a future administration will cut before it is ever laid down
Other weapons & military systems
Leonardo Da Vinci's war machines giant crossbow; aerial screw Architronito steam cannon
Many German WWII-era late-stage 'Wunderwaffe' have been interpreted as performative proposals
Either advertised for propaganda purposes, or pushed by engineers eager to demonstrate their importance to the war effort in order to avoid conscription to the Eastern Front.
Construction, architecture & infrastructure
Atlantropa plan to drain the Mediterranean
Fusing Europe and Africa into one super continent
Transatlantic tunnel using vacuum or air-pressurized tunnels for train transportation
Buckminster Fuller's city-sized geodesic domes or 'Cloud Nine' airborne spherical habitats levitated by heat differential of the internal and external air
Various proposals for arcology mega-structures or ultra-tall skyscrapers
An artificial mountain for weather modification
The UAE commissioned a $400K study on building a mountain to force rain; most likely a PR mega-project rather than a serious proposal.
Mall of the World
2012 UAE proposal for the largest shopping centre, over 4,500,000 square meters
Archigram's 1960s proposals for flexible cities
Including proposals for: (1) 'Plug-In City' (the city as a permanent mega-structure carrying circulation, cranes, and service networks, where modular prefabricated housing units are treated as disposable, replaceable components, removed when they wear out; (2) 'Instant City', a set-up where traveling airships, trucks, and inflatable structures move infrastructure, projection screens, stages, and broadcast equipment into smaller towns, setting up a temporary urban environment; (3) 'Walking City', where large pod-like structures, supported by telescopic legs, contain housing, services, and public facilities within a single mechanical body.
Neom 'the Line' megastructure possible countercase
The envisioned proposal for The Line--"a skyscraper the height of WTC1t and the length of Ireland"--was wildly unserious in its ambition, and amongst others assumes construction costs that are 10x lower than achievable with modern building techniques. -- and indeed, by 2024 ambitions were significantly scaled back; by 2025, after USD 50 bn spent, and funding drying up, work had effectively stopped. (arguably a case of abandoned development)
Consumer products & novelties
Atomic pens
Using radioactive isotopes to heat the ink to produce a selectable range of line densities; used for marketing by Parker Pen, as a tie-in to their use as props in 2001: A Space Odyssey
Lost ‘dark matter’ innovations 2
Fields where something depressed the innovation rate for broad classes of inventions, though it is hard to point at specific artifacts or projects that we were consequently denied.
Cross-cutting
WWII invention-secrecy orders on US patent applications
During World War II, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office deployed its Compulsory Invention Secrecy doctrine to withold patent rights for more than 11,000 patent applications, prohibiting their disclosure to prevent technology leakage. While these orders were rescinded en masse at the end of the war, it caused firms to shift their patenting away from the affected classes, with effects persisting through at least 1960.
Product-liability chill on US innovation (1980s–1990s)
In the 1980s and 1990s, high expected product liability costs depressed US innovation, terminating or reducing research (in domains such as contraceptive products), or reducing production of various technologies (e.g. the number of US firms producing vaccines for childhood diseases fell from 13 to 3 in the 1980s; a similar affect befell US private aircraft production)
Changelog
v0.1 (20 November 2026): first public draft, 495 cases. My own entries, plus the entries and candidates finished in the review so far. Case IDs (STT-0001 and so on) are permanent: they will not change when an entry is edited, moved or renamed.